Introduction

In a landmark judgment with far-reaching implications for India’s taxation framework, Special Economic Zones (SEZs), and the power sector, the Supreme Court of India has categorically ruled that customs duty cannot be levied on electricity generated within a Special Economic Zone and supplied to the Domestic Tariff Area (DTA).

The ruling came while deciding an appeal filed by Adani Power Limited, which had challenged the continued levy of customs duty on electrical energy generated in its SEZ-based power project and supplied to consumers in the DTA.

At its core, the judgment reinforces a foundational principle of Indian constitutional law: no tax can be imposed or collected without clear authority of law. The Court held that the absence of a statutory charging provision under the Customs Act, 1962 could not be cured through exemption notifications, delegated legislation, or changes in duty rates.

This decision is not merely about one company or one sector. It reasserts constitutional discipline under Articles 14 and 265 of the Constitution of India, strengthens judicial precedent, and provides much-needed clarity for SEZ developers, power generators, policymakers, and tax authorities across the country.

Background of the Dispute

Adani Power’s SEZ-Based Power Project

Adani Power Limited operates a thermal power generation unit located within a Special Economic Zone, a legally notified area established to promote exports, investment, and economic development through fiscal and regulatory incentives.

Electricity generated from this SEZ unit was supplied to the Domestic Tariff Area (DTA), i.e., the rest of India outside the SEZ. Under the SEZ framework, goods supplied from an SEZ to the DTA are treated as “imports” for limited purposes, primarily to determine applicable duties and taxes.

The Government’s Attempt to Levy Customs Duty

Despite the fact that imported electrical energy attracts a nil rate of customs duty, the Union Government issued a series of notifications starting from 2010, attempting to levy customs duty on electricity supplied from SEZs to the DTA on a per-unit basis.

These notifications sought to treat electricity generated within India—but inside an SEZ—as if it were imported goods, thereby making it liable for customs duty.

The First Round: Gujarat High Court’s 2015 Judgment

Adani Power challenged these notifications before the Gujarat High Court. In its landmark judgment dated 15 July 2015, the High Court struck down the levy.

Key Findings of the Gujarat High Court (2015)

The High Court held that:

1. Electricity generated within India cannot be treated as “imported goods”

2. There was no charging event under Section 12 of the Customs Act

3. Delegated legislation under Section 25 (exemption notifications) cannot create a tax where none exists

4. Levying customs duty in this manner violated Article 265 of the Constitution, which mandates that tax must be authorised by law

5. The levy also offended Article 14, as it destroyed parity between imported electricity (nil duty) and domestically generated electricity

This declaration of law was later affirmed by the Supreme Court, thereby giving it binding force.

The Second Round: Continued Levy and the 2019 High Court Judgment

Despite the clear declaration of law in 2015, customs authorities continued to levy and collect duty for later periods, relying on subsequent notifications that revised the rate or structure of duty.

When Adani Power sought refunds and enforcement of the earlier judgment, a coordinate bench of the Gujarat High Court in 2019 denied relief. The High Court reasoned that since the later notifications were not specifically challenged, the benefit of the 2015 ruling could not be extended automatically.

This narrow interpretation led to the present appeal before the Supreme Court.

Issues Before the Supreme Court

The Supreme Court was called upon to decide:

1. Whether customs duty could legally be levied on electricity supplied from an SEZ to the DTA

2. Whether later notifications could revive a levy already declared illegal

3. Whether a citizen must repeatedly challenge successive notifications based on the same invalid legal foundation

4. Whether the 2015 judgment had continuing and binding effect

Supreme Court’s Analysis and Observations

A Bench comprising Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice N.V. Anjaria undertook a detailed constitutional and statutory analysis.

1. Absence of a Charging Event Under the Customs Act

The Court reaffirmed that Section 12 of the Customs Act is the charging provision for customs duty. It applies only when there is import into, or export out of, India.

The Court categorically held:

“Electrical energy generated within India and wheeled into the Domestic Tariff Area is not, in truth, a case of import into India.”

Since electricity was generated domestically, the fundamental taxable event itself was missing.

2. Electricity Is Not “Imported Goods” in This Context

Although the SEZ Act treats supplies from SEZs to the DTA as imports for certain purposes, this legal fiction cannot override constitutional or statutory limits.

The Court clarified that:

1. Legal fictions must be strictly confined to the purpose for which they are created

2. They cannot be expanded to create a tax where the charging provision does not exist

3. Limits of Delegated Legislation Under Section 25

The Union argued that subsequent notifications issued under Section 25 of the Customs Act justified the levy.

The Court rejected this argument outright, holding that:

1. Section 25 only grants power to exempt or modify existing duties

2. It cannot create a new levy

3. Delegated legislation cannot cure the absence of legislative competence

The Court observed that what Parliament itself cannot do directly, cannot be done indirectly through subordinate legislation.

4. Parity Principle Under the SEZ Act

Under Section 30 of the SEZ Act, goods cleared from an SEZ to the DTA are chargeable to duties “as applicable to imported goods”.

The Supreme Court emphasised the parity principle:

1. Imported electricity attracts nil customs duty

2. Therefore, electricity supplied from an SEZ to the DTA cannot be subjected to a higher or different duty

Since this statutory position remained unchanged after 2015, the Court found no justification for a different outcome in later years.

5. Binding Nature of the 2015 Declaration of Law

One of the most significant aspects of the judgment is its reaffirmation of judicial discipline and precedent.

The Court held:

“Once a declaration of law is rendered and affirmed by this Court, it acquires binding normative force and governs all transactions resting on the same legal footing.”

The 2019 High Court decision was criticised for narrowing the scope of a coordinate bench’s judgment without referring the matter to a larger bench, which violated settled principles of judicial propriety.

6. No Need to Repeatedly Challenge Identical Illegality

The Supreme Court rejected the argument that Adani Power should have separately challenged every subsequent notification.

It held that:

1. Courts do not function on “technical formalism”

2. A citizen cannot be compelled to repeatedly litigate against the same illegality clothed in different forms

3. Once the foundation of a levy is struck down, all derivative actions fall automatically

7. Colourable Exercise of Power

The Court characterised the impugned notifications as a “colourable exercise of delegated power”, observing that merely altering the rate or timing of the levy does not legitimise an unconstitutional tax.

Constitutional Dimensions of the Judgment

Article 265: Authority of Law

Article 265 of the Constitution mandates:

“No tax shall be levied or collected except by authority of law.”

The Supreme Court reaffirmed that executive convenience or revenue considerations cannot override constitutional mandates.

Article 14: Equality Before Law

The levy was also found to violate Article 14, as it created arbitrary discrimination between:

1. Imported electricity (nil duty)

2. Domestically generated electricity supplied from SEZs

Final Decision and Directions

The Supreme Court:

1. Set aside the 2019 judgment of the Gujarat High Court

2. Allowed the appeal filed by Adani Power Limited

3. Declared that the customs duty levied on electricity supplied from SEZs to the DTA lacked authority of law

4. Directed the Union of India and customs authorities to refund the amounts collected, after verification, without interest

5. Ordered that no further demands be enforced for the period covered by the appeal

Importantly, the Court clarified that:

Its findings are confined to the existing statutory framework and do not prevent Parliament from enacting a future legislative regime, if it so chooses.

Broader Implications of the Judgment

For SEZ Developers and Power Producers

1. Provides long-term tax certainty

2. Prevents retrospective or indirect levies

3. Reinforces investor confidence in SEZ policy

For Tax Administration

1. Reaffirms limits of delegated legislation

2. Emphasises constitutional compliance over revenue considerations

For Constitutional Jurisprudence

1. Strengthens the doctrine of precedent

2. Protects taxpayers from repetitive litigation

3. Upholds the rule of law

Cause Title and Appearances

Case: Adani Power Limited & Anr. v. Union of India & Ors.
Neutral Citation: 2026 INSC 1

For the Appellant:
Senior Advocate P. Chidambaram

For the Respondents:
Raghvendra P. Shankar, Additional Solicitor General

Conclusion

The Supreme Court’s ruling in favour of Adani Power is a landmark affirmation of constitutional tax discipline. By holding that customs duty cannot be levied on electricity supplied from SEZs in the absence of a statutory charging event, the Court has reinforced the supremacy of law over executive action.

More importantly, the judgment sends a clear message: illegal levies cannot be sustained through procedural manoeuvres, altered rates, or repeated notifications. Stability, predictability, and respect for judicial outcomes remain central to India’s constitutional order.

For businesses, policymakers, and legal practitioners alike, this decision stands as a powerful reminder that taxation must always flow from law—not convenience.

Starting a new business venture can be an exhilarating journey filled with excitement and promise. However, amidst the excitement, it's crucial for entrepreneurs to ensure that their startup is compliant with all the legal regulations in India. Failure to adhere to these regulations can lead to severe consequences, including fines, penalties, or even the closure of the business. In this guide, we'll provide a comprehensive checklist of legal compliances that startups in India need to consider.

1. Business Structure and Registration

• Choose the Right Business Structure: Decide whether your startup will be a sole proprietorship, partnership, limited liability partnership (LLP), private limited company, or public limited company. Each structure has its own legal implications, so choose wisely based on your business needs.

• Register Your Business: Once you've chosen a business structure, register your startup with the appropriate authorities. For example, private limited companies must be registered with the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA), while LLPs need to be registered with the Registrar of Companies (ROC).

2. Taxation and Compliance

• Obtain a Permanent Account Number (PAN): Every business entity in India must have a PAN issued by the Income Tax Department. This is essential for filing taxes and conducting financial transactions.

• Goods and Services Tax (GST) Registration: If your startup's annual turnover exceeds the threshold limit prescribed by the GST Act, you must register for GST. Failure to do so can result in penalties.

• Tax Deduction at Source (TDS): If your startup makes payments to vendors, employees, or contractors, you may be required to deduct TDS and remit it to the government within the specified time frame.

3. Intellectual Property Protection

• Trademark Registration: Protect your startup's brand name, logo, and other distinctive elements by registering them as trademarks with the Trademark Registry. This prevents others from using similar marks, thus safeguarding your brand identity.

• Copyright Registration: If your startup creates original works such as software, content, or artistic creations, consider registering them for copyright protection. This grants you exclusive rights to reproduce, distribute, and monetize your creations.

• Patent Registration: If your startup invents a new product, process, or technology, you may be eligible for patent protection. This prevents others from copying or exploiting your invention without your permission.

4. Employment Laws

• Employment Contracts: Draft comprehensive employment contracts that clearly outline the terms and conditions of employment, including salary, benefits, working hours, leave policies, and termination clauses.

• Provident Fund (PF) and Employee State Insurance (ESI): If your startup employs more than a certain number of employees, you must register for PF and ESI schemes and contribute to them regularly.

• Prevention of Sexual Harassment (POSH) Act: Create a safe and harassment-free workplace by implementing policies and procedures in compliance with the POSH Act. Provide awareness training to employees and establish an Internal Complaints Committee (ICC) to address complaints of sexual harassment.

5. Data Protection and Privacy

• General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) Compliance: If your startup deals with the personal data of individuals in the European Union (EU), ensure compliance with the GDPR's stringent data protection requirements.

• Personal Data Protection Bill (PDPB): Stay updated on the latest developments regarding the PDPB, which aims to regulate the processing of personal data in India. Implement necessary measures to protect the privacy and confidentiality of data collected from customers and employees.

6. Regulatory Compliance

• Sector-Specific Regulations: Depending on the nature of your startup's business activities, you may be subject to industry-specific regulations imposed by regulatory authorities such as the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), or Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI).

• Environmental Regulations: Ensure compliance with environmental laws and obtain necessary permits or clearances if your startup's operations have the potential to impact the environment adversely.

Conclusion

Navigating the legal landscape can be daunting for startups, but ensuring compliance with relevant laws and regulations is essential for long-term success and sustainability. By following this comprehensive checklist and seeking professional guidance when needed, startups in India can mitigate legal risks and focus on achieving their business goals with confidence. Remember, compliance isn't just a legal obligation—it's a strategic imperative that fosters trust, credibility, and growth in the competitive startup ecosystem.

In the realm of real estate, understanding taxation is crucial, especially when it comes to the Goods and Services Tax (GST). GST has had a significant impact on various sectors since its implementation. When it comes to buying or selling flats and real estate properties, comprehending the GST rates is essential. In this blog, we'll delve into the nuances of GST rates on real estate and flat purchases, making it easy to understand for everyone.

Introduction to GST in Real Estate

GST, introduced in India in 2017, aims to simplify the taxation system by subsuming multiple indirect taxes. It is levied on the supply of goods and services across the country. In the case of real estate, GST is applicable to the sale of under-construction properties or flats. However, ready-to-move-in properties are exempt from GST as they do not involve the transfer of goods and services.

GST Rates on Real Estate

The GST rates applicable to real estate transactions depend on various factors such as the type of property, its construction status, and the presence of affordable housing components. As of the latest information available, the GST rates for real estate are as follows:

1. Under-construction Flats: For under-construction properties, the GST rate is generally 5%. This rate is applicable to both residential and commercial properties.

2. Affordable Housing Projects: Affordable housing projects enjoy a lower GST rate of 1%. To qualify as an affordable housing project, the property must meet certain criteria specified by the government, such as the carpet area and the selling price.

3. Other Charges: It's important to note that GST is applicable not only on the basic selling price of the property but also on other charges such as preferential location charges, floor rise charges, and amenities charges.

Calculation of GST on Real Estate Transactions

Calculating GST on real estate transactions involves considering various components of the property's cost. Here's a simplified way to calculate GST on the purchase of under-construction flats:

1. Determine the Basic Selling Price (BSP): The BSP is the primary cost of the property excluding other charges.

2. Add Other Charges: Add other charges such as preferential location charges, amenities charges, etc., to the BSP to arrive at the total cost of the property.

3. Calculate GST: Multiply the total cost of the property by the applicable GST rate (5% for under-construction flats, 1% for affordable housing projects) to determine the GST amount.

4. Total Cost to Buyer: Add the GST amount to the total cost of the property to ascertain the final amount payable by the buyer.

Impact of GST on Real Estate Sector

The introduction of GST has had a mixed impact on the real estate sector. While it has brought in transparency and reduced the cascading effect of taxes, there have been challenges as well.

1. Increased Compliance Burden: Real estate developers need to comply with various GST regulations, which can increase their administrative burden.

2. Cost Implications: The GST on under-construction properties has increased the overall cost for buyers, although the input tax credit provision helps mitigate this to some extent.

3. Boost to Affordable Housing: The lower GST rate for affordable housing projects has incentivized developers to focus on this segment, thereby increasing the supply of affordable homes in the market.

4. Market Dynamics: The implementation of GST has also influenced market dynamics, with buyers showing a preference for ready-to-move-in properties to avoid GST implications.

Understanding Input Tax Credit (ITC)

One of the significant provisions under GST for real estate is Input Tax Credit (ITC). ITC allows developers to claim credit for the GST paid on inputs such as raw materials, services, etc., against the GST liability on the sale of properties. This helps in reducing the overall tax liability and can potentially lower the property prices.

However, it's important to note that ITC is available only for under-construction properties and not for ready-to-move-in properties. Also, the developer must pass on the benefit of ITC to the buyers by way of reducing the property prices.

Conclusion

In conclusion, understanding the GST rates on real estate and flat purchases is essential for both buyers and developers. While GST has brought in much-needed reforms to the taxation system, its implications on the real estate sector are significant. Buyers should carefully consider the GST implications while purchasing under-construction properties, and developers must ensure compliance with GST regulations while also passing on the benefits to the buyers. With clarity on GST rates and provisions, navigating the real estate market becomes much easier for everyone involved.

Introduction

When selling a property in India, many homeowners often encounter the term "TDS" or Tax Deducted at Source. Understanding how much TDS is deducted on the sale of property is crucial for both buyers and sellers. In this comprehensive guide, we'll delve into the basics of TDS on property sales, including its calculation, applicability, exemptions, and important considerations.

Understanding TDS on Sale of Property

Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) is a mechanism employed by the Indian government to collect taxes at the source of income generation. In the context of property transactions, TDS is applicable on the sale of immovable property and serves as a means to ensure tax compliance.

Calculation of TDS on Sale of Property

The calculation of TDS on the sale of property is relatively straightforward. As per the Income Tax Act, 1961, the buyer is responsible for deducting TDS at the time of making payment to the seller. The TDS rate on the sale of property is 1% of the total sale consideration if the sale value exceeds ₹50 lakhs.

Applicability of TDS

TDS on the sale of property is applicable under the following conditions:

1. Sale Consideration Exceeds ₹50 Lakhs: If the total sale consideration exceeds ₹50 lakhs, TDS becomes applicable at the rate of 1%.

2. Residential Property: TDS is applicable on the sale of residential as well as commercial property.

3. Capital Gains: TDS is also applicable if the property being sold is subject to capital gains tax.

Exemptions from TDS

While TDS is a mandatory requirement in most cases, there are certain exemptions available under specific circumstances:

1. Agricultural Land: TDS is not applicable on the sale of agricultural land.

2. Sale Consideration Below ₹50 Lakhs: If the total sale consideration does not exceed ₹50 lakhs, TDS is not required to be deducted.

3. NRI Sellers: In the case of Non-Resident Indian (NRI) sellers, the TDS rate may vary, and certain exemptions or lower TDS rates may apply based on Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements (DTAA).

Important Considerations

When dealing with TDS on the sale of property, it's essential to keep the following considerations in mind:

1. TDS Certificate (Form 16B): The buyer is required to furnish a TDS certificate (Form 16B) to the seller as proof of TDS deduction. This certificate contains details of the TDS deducted and deposited with the government.

2. TAN (Tax Deduction and Collection Account Number): The buyer must have a TAN to deduct TDS on the sale of property. It's essential to ensure compliance with this requirement to avoid penalties.

3. Timeline for Deposit: The TDS deducted must be deposited with the government within the specified timeline. Failure to do so may attract penalties and interest.

4. Filing of TDS Returns: The buyer is also responsible for filing TDS returns with the Income Tax Department within the prescribed due dates.

Conclusion

TDS on the sale of property is a crucial aspect of tax compliance in India. By understanding the basics of TDS calculation, applicability, exemptions, and important considerations, both buyers and sellers can navigate property transactions with ease. It's advisable to seek professional guidance to ensure adherence to tax regulations and avoid any potential pitfalls associated with TDS on property sales.

Introduction

In the world of finance and investment, the term "capital gains tax" often surfaces, presenting both an opportunity for profit and a responsibility to pay taxes. While many investors are familiar with the concept of capital gains tax, understanding the nuances of short-term capital gains tax and its exemptions is crucial for optimizing investment strategies and minimizing tax liabilities. In this comprehensive guide, we'll delve into the basics of short-term capital gains tax, explore how it differs from long-term capital gains tax, and uncover potential exemptions investors can leverage to their advantage.

What is Short-Term Capital Gains Tax?

Capital gains tax is a levy imposed on the profit earned from the sale of assets such as stocks, bonds, real estate, or other investments. When an investor sells an asset for more than they initially paid for it, they realize a capital gain. The tax is then applied to this gain.

Short-term capital gains tax specifically applies to profits earned from the sale of assets held for one year or less. The tax rate on short-term capital gains is typically higher than that of long-term capital gains, which applies to assets held for more than one year. The rationale behind this distinction is to incentivize long-term investment and provide potential tax benefits for investors who hold assets for extended periods.

How is Short-Term Capital Gains Tax Calculated?

The calculation of short-term capital gains tax is relatively straightforward. It involves determining the difference between the sale price of the asset and its original purchase price. The resulting profit is then subject to the applicable short-term capital gains tax rate.

Short-term capital gains tax rates align with ordinary income tax brackets. This means that the rate at which short-term capital gains are taxed depends on the investor's total taxable income for the year. Generally, individuals in higher tax brackets face higher short-term capital gains tax rates.

Difference Between Short-Term and Long-Term Capital Gains Tax

Understanding the disparity between short-term and long-term capital gains tax is pivotal for investors looking to optimize their tax liabilities. While short-term capital gains tax applies to profits earned from assets held for one year or less, long-term capital gains tax applies to assets held for more than one year.

One of the key distinctions between the two is the tax rate. Long-term capital gains tax rates are typically lower than short-term capital gains tax rates. This discrepancy is designed to encourage investors to hold assets for longer durations, thereby stimulating economic growth and stability.

Exemptions from Short-Term Capital Gains Tax

Despite the obligation to pay taxes on short-term capital gains, there exist several exemptions and strategies that investors can employ to mitigate their tax liabilities. Here are some noteworthy exemptions:

1. Exemption for Certain Assets:

Certain assets may qualify for exemptions from short-term capital gains tax. For example, investments in qualified small business stock (QSBS) may be eligible for partial or full exemptions from capital gains tax under specific conditions outlined in the tax code. Similarly, investments in Opportunity Zones, designated economically distressed areas, may offer tax incentives, including capital gains tax deferral and reduction.

2. Capital Loss Deductions:

Investors can offset their short-term capital gains by deducting capital losses incurred from other investments. This strategy involves selling assets that have depreciated in value to offset the gains realized from profitable investments. By strategically balancing gains and losses, investors can reduce their overall tax liability.

3. Tax-Loss Harvesting:

Tax-loss harvesting is a proactive strategy wherein investors deliberately sell underperforming assets at a loss to offset capital gains and reduce taxable income. This technique can be particularly effective toward the end of the tax year when investors assess their investment portfolios and seek to optimize tax outcomes.

4. Retirement Accounts:

Investments held within retirement accounts such as Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs) or 401(k) plans are often exempt from capital gains tax until withdrawals are made. By leveraging retirement accounts for investment purposes, individuals can potentially defer capital gains tax and benefit from tax-deferred growth over time.

5. Like-Kind Exchanges (Section 1031 Exchange):

Under certain circumstances, investors may utilize like-kind exchanges, also known as Section 1031 exchanges, to defer capital gains tax on the sale of real estate or other qualifying assets. This provision allows investors to exchange one asset for a similar asset without triggering immediate capital gains tax, thereby facilitating the preservation of investment capital.

Conclusion

Short-term capital gains tax is a crucial aspect of the tax landscape for investors, requiring careful consideration and strategic planning. By understanding the fundamentals of short-term capital gains tax, including its calculation, distinctions from long-term capital gains tax, and available exemptions, investors can navigate the complexities of the tax code more effectively.

While short-term capital gains tax presents a significant financial obligation, savvy investors can leverage exemptions and strategies to optimize their tax outcomes and preserve investment capital. Whether through capital loss deductions, tax-loss harvesting, or strategic investment in retirement accounts, proactive tax planning can yield substantial benefits and contribute to long-term financial success. By staying informed and consulting with tax professionals as needed, investors can position themselves to make informed decisions and maximize their returns while minimizing tax liabilities in the dynamic landscape of investment taxation.