Breach of Contract vs. Breach of Trust: Key Legal Differences Explained

In legal practice, terms like breach of contract and breach of trust are frequently used, yet they are often misunderstood by the general public. Although both terms refer to a failure in fulfilling certain obligations, they emerge from completely different legal relationships and carry distinct legal implications.

Also Read: Know All About The Service Agreement

What is a Breach of Contract?

A contract is a legally binding agreement between two or more parties. Under Section 2(h) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, a contract is defined as “an agreement enforceable by law.” It generally includes essential elements such as:

1. Offer and acceptance

2. Lawful consideration

3. Capacity of parties

4. Free consent

5. Lawful object

A breach of contract occurs when one party fails to fulfill the promises made in the contract without lawful excuse. The failure could be:

1. Total non-performance

2. Delay in performance

3. Defective performance

Example: If A agrees to sell 100 chairs to B by August 1st, but fails to deliver, A has breached the contract.

In such cases, the aggrieved party is entitled to remedies such as compensation, specific performance, or rescission.

Also Read: How Well-Drafted Contracts Help Avoid Costly Legal Penalties and Disputes for Businesses

What is a Breach of Trust?

A trust is a fiduciary relationship in which one person (the trustee) holds property, funds, or confidential information for the benefit of another (the beneficiary). It is governed by honesty, loyalty, and good faith.

A breach of trust occurs when the trustee:

1. Uses the entrusted asset for personal benefit

2. Acts contrary to the trust deed

3. Fails to act in the best interest of the beneficiary

Example: If an employee is given ₹5 lakh for business purchases and uses the money to pay off a personal loan, it constitutes a breach of trust.

This breach is not merely a civil issue — it may attract criminal liability under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023.

Also Read: All You Need to Know About Online Contracts in 2025

Legal Framework for Breach of Trust in India

Civil Law:

• Under Indian trust laws and equitable principles, the court may order:

  1. Restitution of misused property

  2. Compensation to the beneficiary

  3. Removal of the trustee

Criminal Law:

1. Criminal breach of trust is covered under:

   1. Section 316 to 320 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023 (earlier IPC Sections 405 to 409)

2. To constitute a criminal breach of trust, there must be:

   1. Entrustment of property

   2. Dishonest conversion or misuse by the accused

Punishment can include imprisonment (up to 3 or more years) and/or fine, depending on the severity and the nature of the relationship (e.g., employee, agent, public servant).

Also Read: Understanding Breach of Contract: Types, Consequences, and Legal Remedies

Key Differences Between Breach of Contract and Breach of Trust

Although both involve a failure to uphold obligations, their underlying nature, legal remedy, and seriousness vary significantly.

Nature of Relationship

• Breach of Contract: Arises out of a mutual agreement between two or more parties.

• Breach of Trust: Based on a fiduciary relationship where one party is morally and legally bound to act for the benefit of the other.

Type of Duty

• Contract: Duties are defined strictly by the contract — deliver a product, provide a service, or make a payment.

• Trust: The duty is moral and fiduciary — to act in good faith, protect the beneficiary’s interest, and avoid personal gains.

Requirement of Dishonesty

• Breach of Contract: Dishonest intention is not necessary. Even an innocent failure or delay may amount to breach.

• Breach of Trust: Dishonest or fraudulent intention is a key element, especially for criminal liability.

Legal Classification

• Breach of Contract: Always a civil matter.

• Breach of Trust: Can be both civil and criminal, depending on intent and severity.

Legal Provisions

• Contract: Governed by the Indian Contract Act, 1872.

• Trust: Civil provisions are governed by the Indian Trusts Act, 1882; criminal breach of trust is governed by BNS, 2023.

Proof and Burden of Proof

• Contract: Plaintiff must prove:

  1. Existence of a valid contract

  2. Terms and breach

  3. Resulting damages

• Trust: Prosecution must prove:

  1. Entrustment of property

  2. Dishonest misappropriation or misuse

Remedies

Also Read: What Legal Options An Employer Have Against An Employee Who Violated The Notice Period In India

Intent

• Contract: Intent is not mandatory; liability can arise from negligence or oversight.

• Trust: Criminal liability demands dishonest or fraudulent intent.

Scope

• Contract: Wide-ranging — personal, professional, or commercial dealings.

• Trust: Narrow — only where one party is entrusted to act for another’s benefit.

Examples

Breach of Contract:

1. A real estate developer fails to deliver a flat on time.

2. A business fails to pay for goods delivered by a supplier.

Breach of Trust:

1. A lawyer siphons off a client’s funds held in escrow.

2. A treasurer of a charity uses funds for personal luxury.

Illustrative Comparison Table

Also Read: Legal Remedies for Termination of Contracts

Conclusion

In conclusion, breach of contract and breach of trust are two distinct legal concepts rooted in different types of obligations. While breach of contract is a civil wrong based on non-fulfillment of contractual terms, breach of trust involves a deeper ethical and legal failure, often with criminal implications if done dishonestly.

Understanding the nature of these two legal wrongs helps both individuals and businesses protect themselves. Whether you're entering into a contract or entrusting someone with your property or information, it's essential to know the potential legal consequences of a violation.

Being aware of your legal rights and the correct remedies can make all the difference in resolving disputes quickly and justly.

Final Thoughts

When you face a situation where another party has failed in their obligations, identifying whether it is a breach of contract or a breach of trust is crucial. It determines not only the nature of the legal remedy but also the forum where you should file your case — civil or criminal court.

If you're unsure, always consult a legal expert or seek online legal advice from trusted platforms like LegalKart to assess your case and chart the most effective course of action.